Should You Build an App or Use Existing Software?
Custom software isn't always the answer. How to decide between building, buying, combining tools, or automating what you already have.
· 6 min read
We build custom software for a living, and we'll still tell you: sometimes you shouldn't. Existing software is often cheaper, faster, and good enough. Here's how to tell the difference.
When existing software is probably better
- Your process is common. Most businesses like yours work the same way.
- Established products already cover most of what you need.
- You need it running quickly and your budget is limited.
- The software supports your business but isn't what makes it unique.
When a combination of tools works
Sometimes no single product does everything, but three well-chosen tools do. This works well as long as they can share information through built-in integrations.
When a lightweight automation is the answer
If your current tools mostly work but you spend hours copying information between them, a targeted automation or small integration can be the highest-value fix, without replacing anything.
When custom software makes sense
- The software is the product. If you're selling the software, you need to own and control it.
- Your process is a competitive advantage. Generic tools can flatten what makes you different.
- You've tried existing tools and they genuinely don't fit, or you're spending heavily on workarounds.
- You need multiple types of users interacting in a specific way, such as a marketplace.
Questions to ask yourself
- Have I actually trialed the leading products in this category?
- What would I lose by adapting my process to an existing tool?
- How much time or money do the current workarounds cost each month?
- Is this software the business, or does it support the business?
Our Build vs. Buy Assessment asks these questions and gives you an honest initial recommendation, including when an existing product is the better choice.